Back to Blog
Valuation
October 22, 2023
10 min read

How to Determine Price of Antique: Valuation Guide

A
Arthur P. Valuation
Antique Specialist
How to Determine Price of Antique: Valuation Guide

What is My Antique Worth?

One of the most common questions in the world of antiques is, "What is it worth?" Whether you've inherited a family heirloom or found a curious object at a flea market, determining the value of an antique involves several critical factors. It's not just about age; it's about demand, condition, and history.

1. Rarity and Desirability

Just because something is old doesn't mean it's valuable. Value is driven by supply and demand. If an item is rare but no one collects it, it won't fetch a high price. Conversely, some mass-produced items from the mid-20th century are highly sought after today.

Ask yourself: How many of these were made? How many have survived? Is this style currently in fashion?

2. Condition is King

Condition is often the single most important factor in pricing. A mint-condition item can be worth ten times more than the same item with a crack or chip.

  • Mint: Like new, perfect condition.
  • Excellent: Minor signs of wear, no structural damage.
  • Good: Visible wear, minor repairs, but presentable.
  • Poor: Damaged, missing parts, needs restoration.

Note: For some items, like antique furniture or coins, cleaning or "restoring" them can actually decrease their value by removing the original patina. Always check before you clean!

3. Maker's Marks and Signatures

Identifying the manufacturer or artist is crucial. Look for:

  • Stamps on the bottom of pottery or porcelain.
  • Signatures on paintings or sculptures.
  • Labels or tags on furniture.
  • Hallmarks on silver and jewelry.

A known maker usually commands a higher price than an unmarked piece. Use online databases or reference books to look up marks.

4. Provenance

Provenance refers to the documented history of an object. Knowing who owned it previously can add significant value, especially if it belonged to a famous person or has a paper trail going back to its creation. Receipts, old photos, or letters mentioning the item serve as proof of provenance.

5. Current Market Trends

The antique market fluctuates. Brown furniture (traditional mahogany/oak) has seen a dip in value recently, while Mid-Century Modern pieces have soared. To get an accurate price, you need to look at sold listings, not asking prices.

  • Check eBay "Sold" listings.
  • Look at auction house results (e.g., Sotheby's, Christie's, or local auction houses).
  • Use dedicated antique pricing guides like Kovels or WorthPoint.

6. Appraisal vs. Market Value

Understand the difference between different types of value:

  • Retail Value: The price you'd pay at an antique shop (usually the highest).
  • Auction Value: The price it might sell for at an auction (often lower than retail).
  • Insurance Value: The cost to replace the item (usually the highest figure, used for insurance policies).

Conclusion

Determining the price of an antique is an art and a science. By carefully examining your item and researching the current market, you can get a good estimate. However, for high-value items, a professional appraisal is always recommended to ensure you don't undersell your treasure.